Betrayal or Bridge-Building?

[Fatima]

A recent visit by a group of European imams and Islamic scholars to Israel has triggered a wave of criticism across the Muslim world — especially from Al-Azhar, Egypt’s most prestigious Islamic institution. The visit, seen by some as an attempt at religious diplomacy, has been labeled a betrayal of the Palestinian cause by Al-Azhar officials.

What Happened?

A delegation of Muslim religious leaders from Europe traveled to Israel in what was described as a gesture to promote peace, interfaith understanding, and reconciliation. The visit included stops at key religious sites and meetings with Israeli officials.

Al-Azhar’s Strong Response

Al-Azhar, known for its global influence in Islamic scholarship, issued a firm condemnation, calling the visit a stab in the back to Palestinians. The institution emphasized that such visits risk normalizing occupation and injustice, especially in light of the ongoing oppression and suffering in Gaza and the West Bank.

Why the Outrage?

For many in the Muslim world, any engagement with Israel — particularly by religious figures — is seen as legitimizing a state that continues to occupy Palestinian land and violate human rights. Critics argue that visits like this undermine decades of resistance and ignore the daily struggles of Palestinians.

A Divided Response

While Al-Azhar and several Muslim leaders have condemned the visit, others argue that dialogue, even with adversaries, could be a step toward de-escalation. However, in the current political climate, where trust is fragile and violence continues, such gestures are easily misunderstood or rejected outright.

The Bigger Picture

This incident raises deeper questions:

(a) Can religious diplomacy occur without political compromise?
(b) Are such visits truly about peace — or are they being used to whitewash oppression?
(c) And how can Muslim leaders abroad balance local responsibilities with global solidarity?